The Complexity of Simple Geometries or How to Achieve A Ph.D Being a Designer

The Complexity of Simple Geometries or How to Achieve A Ph.D Being a Designer

by Sep 22, 2014
by 风景园林新青年 Sep 22, 2014

by Daniel Angulo Garcia

KEYWORDS: Op art – achieving a Ph.D and being a designer – relating research to design – design contribution to research – research through design

ABSTRACT: In this short article I would like to share my experiences about my actual research and research stage with you. I will explain my research intention and where my interest to this particular topic comes from. Furthermore, I will examine the process of achieving a Ph.D being a designer and discuss some obstacles and difficulties I have faced on the way. To conclude, I will try to answer the question: how design can contribute to research?

INTRODUCTION

Already during my studies and later as a professional architect, I have been interested in the influence of simple geometric systems on our perception of space. Recognizing that in my design work I have always been working within recurring areas of interest motivated me to go a step further and to start researching in a more precise scientific way.

In the following chapters I would like to inform you about the current stage of my research and share my experiences with you about the ongoing process of achieving a Ph.D being a designer.

If you decide to do a Ph.D, the first obstacle or challenge you will face is to find a research topic that profoundly interests you. Since my ongoing research topic was created through my design work, I would like to quickly present you the two key projects that brought me to research. Those projects have been the trigger for my interest doing specific research within a Ph.D.

STARTING POINT (TRIGGER) OF MY RESEARCH: COPTIC CHURCH + URBAN TATTOOS

COPTIC CHURCH (master thesis)

The project ,Coptic Church Torontoʻ is about the beauty of simple and almost banal geometries. The form finding process was strongly attached to a series of experiments trying to find the right patterns and their perfect overlapping arrangements. Those experiments where not only meant to find an ornamental answer but also to fulfill important functions within the project. I call this type of pattern a sensual but meaningful pattern – a poetic interpretation of the ordinary. Apparently complex structures, geometries and patterns appear out of very simple and almost banal systems.

Short Description of the Project:

Position_ the project is about apparently self disturbing contradictions turning into a possibility * it is about the sacrality in every day life, and the every day life in sacrality * it is about both, banality and sacrality * about the border, the in-between and the connecting * not black or white, but gray * imagine divinely enjoying an ice cream in the middle of an endless traffic stream * no cars, no individuals. No individuals, no cathedral. Since there is no cathedral without community, no community without individuals and no individuals without cars in the sprawl, the car is the beginning of the design. At the beginning was the car.

the-complexity-of-simple-geometries-1

URBAN TATOOS

The project ,urban tattoosʻ can also be seen as a trigger for my ongoing research work. First it underlines my interest for urban space and landscape architecture design. Furthermore it was the first time that I realized a project experimenting with the effect of simple geometries on our perception in public space. I considered this project as a ,pathwayʻ laboratory for geometric experiments.

Short Description of the Project:

Remscheid * NRW, Germany. Rather than a city, Remscheid is a conglomerate of forgotten spaces. Just as the city forgot about Gerd Arntz and Wolfgang Tillmanns, it forgot about itself. Statement * What should be done for a city that is not able to understand the meaning of beauty? What should be done for a city that already forgot about itself? What should be done for a city whose districts havenʻt communicated with each other for over a generation? The project is thought as an artistic measure. Only art can react to the townʻs situation and proceed against oblivion. Letʻs get art back from the exile!

the-complexity-of-simple-geometries-2

RESEARCH INTENTION

My research intention crystallizes out of the two projects shown. I am interested in how simple form-giving geometries and visual effects such as rotations, mirroring and overlaying of patterns or pixel surfaces can influence our perception of urban space. These type of visual effects, based on simple geometric systems, were especially explored in artworks during the 50ies through to the 70ies by the so called op-art artists. Francois Morellet for instance, explored how concrete geometries can change the perception of space, by turning, mirroring and overlapping simple geometries.

Since my work is apparently and intrinsically connected to op-art and since op-art was constantly and intuitively influencing my work, the starting point of my research will be op-art.

OP-ART: WORKS IN URBAN SPACE

It appears to me that the first step of my ongoing research should be to show the intrinsic connection between the op-art and contemporary art, design & architectural works. Not only do I intend to depict the inherent influence of op-art and especially of the works from Francois Morellet on contemporary works in urban-space, but will also try to record and categorize their questions in order to transfer those into a more contemporary context.

The connection I am trying to reveal will become more evident looking at Francois Morellets translation of 2 dimensional works into the 3 dimensional space. He called this particular translation ,Architectural Disintegrationʻ which closely grasps onto my field of interest.

(Francois Morellet) 4 DOUBLES GRIDS -1° +1°, -2° +2° (1961) - KAT. 34

(Francois Morellet)
4 DOUBLES GRIDS -1° +1°, -2° +2° (1961) – KAT. 34

And

(Francois Morellet) Integration Archetcturales (he said: architectural disintegration) GRIDS 3° -87° -93° -83° (1971) location: at the plateau La Reynie, at the junction Quincampoix and Aubry-le-Boucher Nearby the centre pompidou... The work does not exist any longer.

(Francois Morellet)
Integration Archetcturales (he said: architectural disintegration)
GRIDS 3° -87° -93° -83° (1971) location: at the plateau La Reynie, at the junction Quincampoix and Aubry-le-Boucher Nearby the centre pompidou… The work does not exist any longer.

An other good example of this kind of translation (Disintegration) can be seen between his ,dashes with space increaseʻ works and the design for the entrance of the Alpexpo in Grenoble, France:

(Francois Morellet) 2 cm dashes with spacing increasing by 2mm every row...

(Francois Morellet)
2 cm dashes with spacing increasing by 2mm every row…

(Francois Morellet & Daniel Jarry) Daniel Jarry for or with Francois Morellet (A translation into space based on Francois Morelletʻs work - every 1, every 2, every 3....) Location: Alpexpo in Grenoble, France (1988). In a very bad condition.

(Francois Morellet & Daniel Jarry)
Daniel Jarry for or with Francois Morellet (A translation into space based on Francois Morelletʻs work – every 1, every 2, every 3….) Location: Alpexpo in Grenoble, France (1988). In a very bad condition.

OP-ART: INFLUENCE IN ART & LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE TODAY

The statement, that there is an evident connection between op-art and many contemporary art, design & architecture works appears to be obvious if we look at the art works of Esther Stocker, Christine Rusche and Stephan Ehrenhöfer (see pictures below).

(Esther Stocker) Silo Barth, 2006, nitro-cellulose lacquer on iron, 15, 7 x 21, 5 m, Brixen / Bressanone, 1974 born in Schlanders, Italien/Italy, LIVING IN AUSTRIA

(Esther Stocker)
Silo Barth, 2006, nitro-cellulose lacquer on iron, 15, 7 x 21, 5 m, Brixen / Bressanone, 1974 born in Schlanders, Italien/Italy, LIVING IN AUSTRIA

(Christine Rusche) DEAD RECKONING + site-specific Sonic Space by Kim Laugs (NL) 12,20 m x 12,40 m x 6,30 m, Dispersionsfarbe/acrylic paint,

(Christine Rusche)
DEAD RECKONING + site-specific Sonic Space by Kim Laugs (NL) 12,20 m x 12,40 m x 6,30 m, Dispersionsfarbe/acrylic paint,
Kunsthalle Mainz, “Illusion&Konsequenz”, Mainz (Germany), 2008-2009

(Stephan Ehrenhöfer) Malerei im raum, Dispersion, projektraum Zürich, 1990

(Stephan Ehrenhöfer)
Malerei im raum, Dispersion, projektraum Zürich, 1990

APPROACH

The images shown above give you an impression of my ongoing research intention. Now I would like to discuss some obstacles and strategies obtaining a Ph.D and being a designer. Since designers aren`t especially trained in scientific working methods, the next step should be to gain those skills.

The ability to do scientific research foresees that the individual trying to achieve a Ph.D should at least know the ,ownʻ rules or paradigms of his/her discipline. Doing a Ph.D within Design disciplines usually required you to transfer paradigms from other disciplines where those were already set up and were generally accepted. Although you can find several impulses trying to fill this gap, design disciplines haven`t yet set up their own paradigms. Opting to acquire the skills I havenʻt been trained for, I started to educate myself in the classical ways of scientific research, trying to adapt those methods to the needs of my (design) research and confronting unexpected problems while searching for the right methods.

Choosing classical research methods means to restrict my ,designerly skillsʻ, concentrating on very strict paradigms such as defining a precise question, determining the state of research, etc. Overall this would be a more secure way in obtaining a Ph.D.

Choosing to find more suitable research methods for designers such as ,design oriented researchʻ or respectively the so called ,research trough designʻ (RTD) means having to set up possible paradigms for design disciplines, a less secure but more appropriate way.

Since beginning my research I have being jumping back and forward between the classic scientific method and finding more suitable research methods for designers, for instance research through design (RTD).

The search for a validation and personal acceptance, and not merely to achieve a Ph.D through a purely accepted scientific way has taken some time. I have come to the conclusion that it would not make sense to do a Ph.D without having found a more suitable way of researching for designers.

I believe in the symbiotic relation of design and research as source of a creative potential for my work. However, I am convinced that the classic scientific working methods as a base will be helpful in mastering the complexity of the subject. „Defining a precise question, determining the state of research, arranging and evaluating the material, and so forth“ will be and have to be part of my work. Nevertheless, I am looking for broader knowledge through a creative approach to the topic of interest, which means a rather associative but not chronological approach.

My actual design skills can be incorporated into the process through a sort of case-study approach, trying to gain as much information as possible out of my practical work, using my actual work as a generator of information. It is very important to clarify that I am not trying to do research about my design projects.

RELATING RESEARCH TO DESIGN

There are overlapping areas between research and design: While designing we do research, archive, categorize and reflect information. We might not do this using a scientific methodology but rather in an undefined way for very specific tasks. Often the gained information becomes part of future tasks and designs as well.

Linda Groat and David Wang assume that while „design as such is not research as such“, „research can aid the design process in many ways“. In their book „architectural research methods“ they state that „the two domains are equal in intellectual significance“ and claim that „efforts should be made to encourage the view that design activity and research activity are of equal value“.

Questions about the relation between science and design are not only a contemporary phenomena but have already been discussed, for instance, by Immanuel Kant, Richard Neutra, Friedrich Kittler and Rudolf Schindler among others.

According to Kant „aesthetic experiences are part of the domain of reason – even though they can not be fully captured by formulas, words or other determinate modes of communication.“ As explained by Groat and Wang „the entire process of art production is indeterminate, that is, it can not be fully captured by determinate descriptions, and yet it is within the domain of reason.“

Richard Neutra stated in1957 in his book „survival through design“ that „the art of design can associate itself with scientific skill and do so without an inferiority complex“.

HOW CAN DESIGN CONTRIBUTE TO RESEARCH

The main contribution of designers to research consists of preventing science from an auto- implosion caused by the self-referring nature of disciplines as described by Michel Foucault. The renewing vigor of designers and their disciplines appear to be exactly what is most needed. Designers may, for instance, help in identifying and perceiving contemporary research topics and by turning into the eyes of the disciplines that have lost their ability to identify or perceive the most essential contemporary tasks and questions.

REVIEW

Besides the great cultural and academic experience, the serious and constructive exchange and discussions, the Joint Seminar has become a great impulse for my ongoing research. Meeting people in similar situations, emphasizes the significance of how intrinsic joining forces can be. Not only were you able to share these issues and questions with other Ph.D candidates, who are also trying to find a more suitable approach for achieving a Ph.D as designers, but also you got firsthand reviews and observations from professors as well.

 >> 点击这里查看本文中文版《几何形体的复杂性——设计师的博士之路》



无觅相关文章插件,快速提升流量

风景园林新青年

风景园林新青年

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

风景园林新青年

风景园林新青年

年报 北欧 图解 意识形态 Mader 场所 广场 人文 瑠公圳 经典 布鲁克林大桥 绿色设计 LEPC 批评 Vista Hermosa 教育 风景园林学会2013年会 原子城 SANAA 德国市民花园 志愿者 喷泉 建筑 华盛顿 棕地 加州花园 枡野俊明 可持续化 地域性景观 多样性 手绘 安藤忠雄 BIM 陈俊愉 流浪汉 视频 张乔松 挪威 商业建筑 IFLA 伊利诺伊大学 UIUC 王欣 合作 Peter Walker 跨学科教育 纪念碑 如园 枯山水 Diana Balmori 刘秀晨 雪铁龙公园 公益 logo 宋晔皓 迪士尼 Disney 护栏 鹿特丹 台湾 国际风景园林师高峰论坛 数字图解 西班牙 工程 Kingston University 岭南园林 就业 北林 古根海姆博物馆 盆景园 幻觉 北角公园 Jack Ahern WEST8 雕塑 墨西哥 文化景观 广州市绿化公司 水景 2013北京园博会 三倾园 Media Ship 沃夫岗·哈勃 湿地 地震 博士 可持续 庭院 Greenway 孟兆祯 环境 希望小学 Gesche Joost 狼牙山 风景园林学会2011年会 马晓暐 香格里拉植物园 翻译 NITA 设计研究 低能耗 青海 开放空间 行业 地砖 区域园林 证书 植物 概念方案 成范永 清华 冯纪忠 托滕堡公园 Hans Joachim Mader 购物中心 学习方法 LABash 俞昌斌 太阳能 风景园林学会2015年会 设计竞赛 盐湖城 国家公园 铺地 视觉文化 北川 华南 捷得国际 预制混凝土 设计展 ARC 碛口古镇 沥青 设计未来城市 联谊 骑行 Dr. Rosan Chow 张唐景观 数字化 康奈尔大学 摄影 裁员 世博 世界风景园林师高峰论坛 鸟类 竞赛 何巧女 植物园 Michael Van Valkenburgh and Associates 托马斯·丘奇 风景区 Juergen Weidinger 永昌河 讲座 环境效应 GSD 调查问卷 香港 生态 James Corner 创业 ASLA学生奖 AGER 可持续城市 数字景观 上海 游乐场 空气污染 教学 几何 朱胜萱 2012IFLA 洪盈玉 旅游 新青年读老经典 钢笔画 风景园林学 Prof. Gesche Joost 绿道 铁路 长椅 北京 绿色基础设施 苏州古典园林 布法罗河湾散步道 新西兰 土人景观 留学 自然文化资源 日本设计 绿色屋顶 夏成钢 树屋 论坛 展览 苗木 弗吉尼亚大学 UVa 禅修 风景园林新青年,就在你身边 京津冀 LIM 政治 公园 西方建筑 职业实践 交通节点 清华同衡学术周 现代主义 中央公园 滨水 维吉尼亚理工大学 西安世园会 Vertical Greening Systems 泰山 法国 卡尔维诺 保护 Ron Henderson Julius Fabos TAMU 城市 雨洪管理 历史 Waterboxx 韩国 公共花园 SWA 技术 龙安寺 城市景观 年会 低收入住宅 参数化设计 英国 矶琦新 经验 天津大学 城市雨水 城市建设 南湖中央公园 RTD 万科 反思 客座教授 迪士尼音乐厅 风景园林 珊瑚礁 机场 种植装置 园博会 Prof. Wolfgang Jonas 教学元素 MLA Stoss Landscape Urbanism 王劲韬 花园 巴塞罗那 水盒子 Prof. Loidl-Reisch 步行街 洛阳 新年 银泉市 Silver Spring 维格兰 Malden 德国 TOPOS 五角大楼 野生动物廊道 罗马奖 9.11 非言述性和默会性知识 碳补偿林 檀馨 buffalo 美国 欧洲 贝聿铭 安友丰 城市空间 马克 布鲁克林 校园 河流 首尔 鹈鹕湾 保研 沙龙 书评 Prof. Jürgen Weidinger 空间 实验 Ruggeri 哈普林 halprin 什刹海 钓鱼岛 辰山植物园 迪拜 深圳前海 Prof. Nigel Cross 美术馆 公共交通 2012IFLA亚太区会议 牛雄 普渡大学 朱育帆 散步道 宾夕法尼亚大学 纪念性景观 雨水 种植 水文 IGA 历史理论 设景 老人 便携 雕塑公园 毕业设计 绿墙 休斯顿探索公园 儿童 Brownfield 禅意 垃圾 玛莎·施瓦茨 铺装 景观都市主义 海平面上升 考研 纽约 Gleisdreieck 自然观 会议 自杀 新加坡 居住区 纵向耕作 方塔园 理论 加拿大 毛细水 城乡 哈佛 风景园林月 韩炳越 灾后 LAM 马萨诸塞大学 UMass ASLA 佛罗里达 人居环境 住宅花园 日本 多伦多 Xeritown